Aiden Fry - SMIG - 2010/11
Testing .... Hello ..... Welcome ......
This is Aiden Fry's Blog page for the SMIG course at Leeds Met covering the years 2010/11.
Wednesday, 3 November 2010
Innovative game audio - Audiosurf
"Audiosurf is a music-adapting puzzle racer where you use your own music to create your own experience. The shape, the speed, and the mood of each ride is determined by the song you choose." - http://www.audio-surf.com/
Developed by Indie developers - Audiosurf llc. Published on Valve 2008.
Audiosurf is a game where players have to race through a course, collecting blocks of different colours. These blocks then stack up in front of the players vehicle. Getting same colour block groups (3 or more in a row/touching) then makes the blocks disappear and the player gains points (Similar to bejeweled/tetris games).
Innovative stuff.
Audiosurf allows the player to import the game audio form their personal music library, because the player can choose the game music a personalised and enjoyable audio field can be created.
When a song is imported into Audiosurf it is analysed using beat recognition (and other analytical) software. The placement of the blocks (throughout the course) is then determined using the data from the rhythm detection.
This means that blocks are syncronised with audio events. E.g. In a busy part of the track there will be lots of blocks, and in a more sparse section of the music the blocks will also become more sparse.
Summing up
Audacity is not the only game which allows players to import their own music (xbox 306 music player, MMO's such as Cabal) but in these examples the music does not affect the game, and there is very little interaction between game and music (maybe duck the music during cutscenes, but thats about it...)But Audiosurf is one of the few games where the audio content directly affects the game play. By affecting race speed and block placement, audiosurf can create personalised generative races that are highly syncronised with the game audio. Allowing players to import their own audio tracks is a really great feature of this game and bring to light the analytical processes that allow audiosurf to create personalised game play based on user choices (which song to play) and the audio content.
Tuesday, 19 October 2010
Spore - Non-Repetitive Audio - Creature Voicing
This is a short video, showing how Spore uses Non - repetitive audio techniques for the creature voices within the creature stage of the game.
Spore has a vast range of call samples at its disposal, the type of call that the creature makes is dependant on a few things. The type of mouth on the creature (Beak = bird calls.. etc), the size of the creature (bigger generally = lower pitch calls) and the creatures mood state (angry, sad, happy etc.)
This is also an example of procedural audio as Spore is processing incoming game data in real time (especially in the creator mode) and making decisions about the sound the creature(s) will make.
Spore uses, pitch changers, volume modifiers, decision making procedures, a large library of raw sounds, combinators and modulators to create a non-repetitive audio system for creature calls.
Also the ambience in Spore uses random and concaternater audio devices to create a vivid audio environment for the user, without the use of obvious loops and repetition which could remove the player from the immersion of the game.
Thanks for reading.
Aiden
Spore has a vast range of call samples at its disposal, the type of call that the creature makes is dependant on a few things. The type of mouth on the creature (Beak = bird calls.. etc), the size of the creature (bigger generally = lower pitch calls) and the creatures mood state (angry, sad, happy etc.)
This is also an example of procedural audio as Spore is processing incoming game data in real time (especially in the creator mode) and making decisions about the sound the creature(s) will make.
Spore uses, pitch changers, volume modifiers, decision making procedures, a large library of raw sounds, combinators and modulators to create a non-repetitive audio system for creature calls.
Also the ambience in Spore uses random and concaternater audio devices to create a vivid audio environment for the user, without the use of obvious loops and repetition which could remove the player from the immersion of the game.
Thanks for reading.
Aiden
Tuesday, 12 October 2010
An example of Algorithmic Music - Boids
Boids is an algorithmic music compositional tool, with elements of interactivity. The user/composer/player can use the mouse to change certain parameters and affect a semi-randomly generated audio field.
Boids uses a bird and animal flocking algorithm (created to plot the dinosaur's flocking movements in the Jurassic Park films). In Boids the flocking algorithm is used in a variety of means to decide pitch/velocity/specialising/rhythm/etc. for each melody line. User choices, the algorithm and other random elements all add up to create the final musical content.
Although listening to this clip again it does seem like there are some elements of repetitiveness, such as there is quite a distinctive pulse (in this clip anyway) and the timbre of the synthesised noises stay relatively constant, although filters and pitch change dramatically.
Another example of Algorithmic Composition.
This is a small/basic algorithmic music generator, that I created in Max/Msp 5.
It uses only 3 samples (Snake hiss, Leopard Growl, Dog Bark) and a number of sfplay~ objects.
On the more musical "instruments" called labelled "blippers" - Play, Loop on/off, Pitch and Velocity functions are all semi-randomly generated (flicking between presets that I have defined).
On the Drums a predefined kick/snare pattern has been set, but high hats are randomly generated.
The user can Reset the drum loop (triggering a kick drum on next beat), and turn on/off the "blippers", which can give the piece structure.
Within this piece there are no higher order algorithms (for now....), defining structure, or taking into account what music has gone before, which can make this piece sound a little flat. After a couple of minutes run time, a user/listener is likely to become bored and switch off.
Cheers for reading.
Aiden
Monday, 4 October 2010
S&M for Interactivity - Week 1 - An example of bad game audio, with analysis [DARK VOID]
Short: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LfTBIMNB3yc&feature=fvw
Longer: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QkRgD7wGegc
Above are two clips from the game Dark Void, released by Capcom in Spring 2010. Dark void is set in the 1940's and features aliens, jet packs, massive machine/monsters and takes place in another universe called "the Void" which is accessible through a portal in the bermuda triangle.... Whilst this all sound fairly interesting, my personal experience of this game was that it felt, repetitive and un-engaging, the story-line was inconsistent and eventually I got bored of shooting up wave after wave of unconvincing alien soldiers and never played the game again. I believe that the audio in Dark Void negatively affected my experience as a whole, and this is why.
I will start by analysing the first clip supplied above (The short one). Admittedly this is a youtube clip that I have not recorded my self, so it would be fair to say the the quality of the audio has probably been reduced by a fair degree, I will try to take this into account upon analysis. In the first scene of the clip (0:06) there is a variety of very loud and deep thunder crackles/rumbles, firstly it is hard to discern what in-game action these sounds are supposed to represent; engine/jet pack noise, explosions or even a thunder clap. Secondly, it sounds as if the sound designer has used a low sample rate for some of these noises, which gives them a murky, muffled feel (although this is made worse by the youtube sound quality). At (0:10) when the playable character starts to hover the low rumbling sounds just seem to disappear, leaving a discernible "Void" in the audio field. Suddenly you realise that the jet pack strapped to your back is barely making any noise at all, whilst the gunfire emitting from your weapon is incredibly loud.
I think that more care should have be taken when down sampling the low rumbling audio in this scene. The muffled quality to the audio, plus the question of "what is making that noise?" detracts from the player immersion in this scene, and throughout the game. Whilst, wildly inconsistent levelling (In my mind a jet pack and gun should be roughly the same volume) could leave the player a bit disorientated, once again removing the illusion of immersion.
Ok moving on, the next scene (scene two - 0:13) features an alien machine / robot lizard. This machine looks huge and probably weighs a few thousand tonnes, and the sound of its footsteps seems to back that idea up. Now take a minute to listen for the whirring/grinding engine and hydraulic noises that you would expect to hear from a massive robo-beast. The audio associated with this machine (too me anyway) suggests that this huge killing machine is actually a printer... This inconsistency of audio size and scale detracts from the awe/freight/exhilaration that the player should feel when battling with such a mighty foe.
Scene three (0:25). This scene is a great example of what I think is the worst and most annoying gunshot noises ever created. As you have heard throughout these clips the gunshot noise is VERY loud, and sounds more like a thud than a controlled explosion, but the main problems I find with the gunshot audio is that it is hard to hear the ricochet/impact noises of the bullets, and is therefor difficult to understand the properties of the surface you are shooting (wood/metal/alien), I am comparing this aspect of the Dark Void game play to other shooters such as COD and Battlefield, where a lot of information is given to the user by the ricochet/impact noises of bullets. Another thing that Dark Void does not do, but COD/Battlefield does, is to use information about the players surrounding to affect the sound of the gunshot. Essentially, the gunshots in Dark Void are not affected by different reverbs for different environments throughout the level. If you look at scene two and scene three you will hear that the gunshot noise is exactly the same, even though the environment has changed dramatically. This lack of audio/environmental feedback does NOT help the user immerse themselves within the game.
Now moving on to my "favourite" scene in this short montage, scene four (0:30). This scene show how sloppy and unthinking the audio programmers have been when designing this game, and also makes me wonder whether they bothered to test the game properly. Moving away from sound effects (which have similar problems in this scene as in scene two) and focusing on the composed music, we hear that there are a number of very abrupt cut's in the sound track (these appear throughout the game). These sharp cuts give an inconsistent feel to the game, and sound like massive errors on behalf of the audio programming team. Simple transition phrases, or at least waiting till the end of the bar before cutting the music, would dramatically improve the players experience of Dark Void. These cuts tend to happen when fighting big boss-like creatures, in a type of semi-cinematic game play that involves doing very specific things and a lot of button tapping. What happens in these scenes are very predictable for the player, let alone the developers, therefor I think that having these abrupt audio cuts show a lack of interest in consistency and creating a smooth "flow" to the game. Finally, dramatic cuts in the music also mean that sound effects can suddenly stand out and can feel empty/sparse.
Now look through the second link that i have provided, you will find more examples of all the issues that I have raised above, and also a few more issues that i would like to discuss...
The noise that indicates that the user has gained a pick up (the gold balls with rings - 2:18), I find to be quite annoying, and also it doesn't sound like a positive noise. As it is part of the game to collect these golden pick-ups to pay for upgrades to your character, a noise that provides better positive re-enforcement could have been more suitable, E.g. the Coin pick up noise in Sonic the Hedgehog (A very basic example i know).
Another issue is when the character collects up a red pick up item (tech point cache - 4:26) a silent menu pops up, cutting off all game noise in an instant. Once again the red pick up's are very useful to the characters development within the game, but there is no positive audio re-enforcement of this, in fact the silence (the only true silence within the game) is very unnerving, and only adds to the feeling of inconsistency that is rife throughout Dark Void.
The main ways that I would improve the audio in Dark Void, is to make better use of levelling, giving the user a more consistent and believable audio field, with few or hopefully no sudden unrealistic cuts in volume (Music and SFX), this will help make the audio relate and integrate more to the visuals. I would use the audio to give a more detailed impression of the environment using different reverbs on important sounds such as footsteps and gunshots, also I would have liked too use a more varied impact/ricochet sound library, this should help immerse the player in the game more.
Finally, it seems (too me) that there are a few fundamental mistakes within the audio programming of Dark Void that makes the audio package sound a bit rushed, as if it wasn't any real time for testing and re-editing. The most important thing that I would do differently is to spend more time being picky, testing and editing the audio until there is a polished and consistent final product.
Aiden Fry - SMIG - 04/10/2010
Longer: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QkRgD7wGegc
Above are two clips from the game Dark Void, released by Capcom in Spring 2010. Dark void is set in the 1940's and features aliens, jet packs, massive machine/monsters and takes place in another universe called "the Void" which is accessible through a portal in the bermuda triangle.... Whilst this all sound fairly interesting, my personal experience of this game was that it felt, repetitive and un-engaging, the story-line was inconsistent and eventually I got bored of shooting up wave after wave of unconvincing alien soldiers and never played the game again. I believe that the audio in Dark Void negatively affected my experience as a whole, and this is why.
I will start by analysing the first clip supplied above (The short one). Admittedly this is a youtube clip that I have not recorded my self, so it would be fair to say the the quality of the audio has probably been reduced by a fair degree, I will try to take this into account upon analysis. In the first scene of the clip (0:06) there is a variety of very loud and deep thunder crackles/rumbles, firstly it is hard to discern what in-game action these sounds are supposed to represent; engine/jet pack noise, explosions or even a thunder clap. Secondly, it sounds as if the sound designer has used a low sample rate for some of these noises, which gives them a murky, muffled feel (although this is made worse by the youtube sound quality). At (0:10) when the playable character starts to hover the low rumbling sounds just seem to disappear, leaving a discernible "Void" in the audio field. Suddenly you realise that the jet pack strapped to your back is barely making any noise at all, whilst the gunfire emitting from your weapon is incredibly loud.
I think that more care should have be taken when down sampling the low rumbling audio in this scene. The muffled quality to the audio, plus the question of "what is making that noise?" detracts from the player immersion in this scene, and throughout the game. Whilst, wildly inconsistent levelling (In my mind a jet pack and gun should be roughly the same volume) could leave the player a bit disorientated, once again removing the illusion of immersion.
Ok moving on, the next scene (scene two - 0:13) features an alien machine / robot lizard. This machine looks huge and probably weighs a few thousand tonnes, and the sound of its footsteps seems to back that idea up. Now take a minute to listen for the whirring/grinding engine and hydraulic noises that you would expect to hear from a massive robo-beast. The audio associated with this machine (too me anyway) suggests that this huge killing machine is actually a printer... This inconsistency of audio size and scale detracts from the awe/freight/exhilaration that the player should feel when battling with such a mighty foe.
Scene three (0:25). This scene is a great example of what I think is the worst and most annoying gunshot noises ever created. As you have heard throughout these clips the gunshot noise is VERY loud, and sounds more like a thud than a controlled explosion, but the main problems I find with the gunshot audio is that it is hard to hear the ricochet/impact noises of the bullets, and is therefor difficult to understand the properties of the surface you are shooting (wood/metal/alien), I am comparing this aspect of the Dark Void game play to other shooters such as COD and Battlefield, where a lot of information is given to the user by the ricochet/impact noises of bullets. Another thing that Dark Void does not do, but COD/Battlefield does, is to use information about the players surrounding to affect the sound of the gunshot. Essentially, the gunshots in Dark Void are not affected by different reverbs for different environments throughout the level. If you look at scene two and scene three you will hear that the gunshot noise is exactly the same, even though the environment has changed dramatically. This lack of audio/environmental feedback does NOT help the user immerse themselves within the game.
Now moving on to my "favourite" scene in this short montage, scene four (0:30). This scene show how sloppy and unthinking the audio programmers have been when designing this game, and also makes me wonder whether they bothered to test the game properly. Moving away from sound effects (which have similar problems in this scene as in scene two) and focusing on the composed music, we hear that there are a number of very abrupt cut's in the sound track (these appear throughout the game). These sharp cuts give an inconsistent feel to the game, and sound like massive errors on behalf of the audio programming team. Simple transition phrases, or at least waiting till the end of the bar before cutting the music, would dramatically improve the players experience of Dark Void. These cuts tend to happen when fighting big boss-like creatures, in a type of semi-cinematic game play that involves doing very specific things and a lot of button tapping. What happens in these scenes are very predictable for the player, let alone the developers, therefor I think that having these abrupt audio cuts show a lack of interest in consistency and creating a smooth "flow" to the game. Finally, dramatic cuts in the music also mean that sound effects can suddenly stand out and can feel empty/sparse.
Now look through the second link that i have provided, you will find more examples of all the issues that I have raised above, and also a few more issues that i would like to discuss...
The noise that indicates that the user has gained a pick up (the gold balls with rings - 2:18), I find to be quite annoying, and also it doesn't sound like a positive noise. As it is part of the game to collect these golden pick-ups to pay for upgrades to your character, a noise that provides better positive re-enforcement could have been more suitable, E.g. the Coin pick up noise in Sonic the Hedgehog (A very basic example i know).
Another issue is when the character collects up a red pick up item (tech point cache - 4:26) a silent menu pops up, cutting off all game noise in an instant. Once again the red pick up's are very useful to the characters development within the game, but there is no positive audio re-enforcement of this, in fact the silence (the only true silence within the game) is very unnerving, and only adds to the feeling of inconsistency that is rife throughout Dark Void.
The main ways that I would improve the audio in Dark Void, is to make better use of levelling, giving the user a more consistent and believable audio field, with few or hopefully no sudden unrealistic cuts in volume (Music and SFX), this will help make the audio relate and integrate more to the visuals. I would use the audio to give a more detailed impression of the environment using different reverbs on important sounds such as footsteps and gunshots, also I would have liked too use a more varied impact/ricochet sound library, this should help immerse the player in the game more.
Finally, it seems (too me) that there are a few fundamental mistakes within the audio programming of Dark Void that makes the audio package sound a bit rushed, as if it wasn't any real time for testing and re-editing. The most important thing that I would do differently is to spend more time being picky, testing and editing the audio until there is a polished and consistent final product.
Aiden Fry - SMIG - 04/10/2010
Thursday, 30 September 2010
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)